Scarleteen is closed for the next two days, so that's Thursday, October 31st (for Halloween) and Friday, November 1st (for Diwali). We'll be back and able to answer your questions on Saturday. Catch you soon!
Menstruation: Shame or No Shame?
-
- scarleteen founder & director
- Posts: 9687
- Joined: Sun Jul 27, 2014 11:43 am
- Age: 54
- Awesomeness Quotient: I have been a sex educator for over 25 years!
- Primary language: english
- Pronouns: they/them
- Sexual identity: queery-queer-queer
- Location: Chicago
Menstruation: Shame or No Shame?
There's been some nicely renewed talk about menstruation -- or more to the point, talk about talking about it -- on and around the 'net lately.
So, where are you at with this yourself? Are periods and menstruation something you feel able to talk about without shame, the same way you'd talk about other body functions, like say, salivating, breathing or digestion? Or not?
And in your life, if menstruation has a part in it (be it your own or someone else's), is it also something you feel like you can and do deal with like other body functions or like you can't, and it's something you feel ashamed of in some way?
(Btw, not making any assumptions here about, for instance, someone wanting some or all of menstruation to be private meaning they must be ashamed, or only wanting to talk about it with others with the same kinds of boundaries a person might want when talking about say, a general health problem or issue meaning someone must be ashamed. I'm figuring you're all smart enough to have a sense of when what you are feeling is shame or not!)
So, where are you at with this yourself? Are periods and menstruation something you feel able to talk about without shame, the same way you'd talk about other body functions, like say, salivating, breathing or digestion? Or not?
And in your life, if menstruation has a part in it (be it your own or someone else's), is it also something you feel like you can and do deal with like other body functions or like you can't, and it's something you feel ashamed of in some way?
(Btw, not making any assumptions here about, for instance, someone wanting some or all of menstruation to be private meaning they must be ashamed, or only wanting to talk about it with others with the same kinds of boundaries a person might want when talking about say, a general health problem or issue meaning someone must be ashamed. I'm figuring you're all smart enough to have a sense of when what you are feeling is shame or not!)
Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has. - Margaret Mead
-
- not a newbie
- Posts: 15
- Joined: Sun Aug 03, 2014 10:09 am
- Age: 34
- Awesomeness Quotient: I make a mean origami dragon
- Primary language: English
- Pronouns: she/her
- Sexual identity: straight
- Location: Canada
Re: Menstruation: Shame or No Shame?
I've never been shy about discussing bodily functions, menstruation included, but I remember in high school realizing that this was something I was expected to hide from male counterparts and, not wanting to break social norms, I found myself slipping into euphemisms and whispers instead of talking about periods freely. I realized that this was something I was supposed to be ashamed of and hide from those that didn't have a uterus, lest they be revolted... or something. I don't know that I ever bought into the shame factor whole heartily but it certainly fed shame I already felt about my body and sexuality in general and kept me from talking and learning from other people's experiences.
I don't know when exactly that stopped but at some point decided that I wasn't going to let arbitrary norms about who was and wasn't ok to discuss periods with dictate my conversations, and man I'm glad I did. I think giving myself the freedom to talk about menstruation also gave me the freedom to be more comfortable with it. Much like with Voldemort, fear of the name (or in this case the talk of periods) only increases fear of the thing itself.
So these days I would say I'm shame free when it comes to periods. I have boundaries about what I'll say, where and to whom, the same as I would for discussion of any bodily function, but none of that derives from pressure to hide something "gross" about myself or shame about what my body does. If anything, these days I'm fascinated to hear about the varied and crazy things our reproductive organs do.
I don't know when exactly that stopped but at some point decided that I wasn't going to let arbitrary norms about who was and wasn't ok to discuss periods with dictate my conversations, and man I'm glad I did. I think giving myself the freedom to talk about menstruation also gave me the freedom to be more comfortable with it. Much like with Voldemort, fear of the name (or in this case the talk of periods) only increases fear of the thing itself.
So these days I would say I'm shame free when it comes to periods. I have boundaries about what I'll say, where and to whom, the same as I would for discussion of any bodily function, but none of that derives from pressure to hide something "gross" about myself or shame about what my body does. If anything, these days I'm fascinated to hear about the varied and crazy things our reproductive organs do.
-
- previous staff/volunteer
- Posts: 10320
- Joined: Mon Jul 28, 2014 9:06 am
- Age: 33
- Awesomeness Quotient: I raise carnivorous plants
- Primary language: english
- Pronouns: she/her
- Sexual identity: queer
- Location: Coast
Re: Menstruation: Shame or No Shame?
I would say that I'm at much the same point Infinitea is. When I use euphemisms or otherwise dance around the subject of menstruation has more to do with the company I'm in than how I feel about those functions (perfectly normal although sometimes extremely aggravating is how I feel about them). I used to be much more self conscious about it, due to having the cycle from hell during middle school (two weeks of heavy bleeding, too-small gaps between periods, etc. Turned out it was PCOS). For a long time, period meant a sudden uptick in my anxiety and the worry that I would have visible blood stains in front of people. My parents, to their credit, have never made menstruation something icky or taboo, so even during the periods from hell I felt like I could at least talk to them and ask for help.
Nowadays, much of my time is spent around either hippies or sex educators, both of whom are not shy about discussing periods. This definitely helped me feel more comfortable discussing them with others. When everyone is swapping diva cups stories in the kitchen, it helps remind you that this is not something to be ashamed of.
Nowadays, much of my time is spent around either hippies or sex educators, both of whom are not shy about discussing periods. This definitely helped me feel more comfortable discussing them with others. When everyone is swapping diva cups stories in the kitchen, it helps remind you that this is not something to be ashamed of.
And you to whom adversity has dealt the final blow/with smiling bastards lying to you everywhere you go/turn to and put out all your strength of arm and heart and brain/and like the Mary Ellen Carter rise again.
-
- not a newbie
- Posts: 90
- Joined: Mon Aug 04, 2014 4:01 am
- Age: 27
- Primary language: English please!
- Pronouns: She/they
- Sexual identity: Pansexual
- Location: New Zealand
Re: Menstruation: Shame or No Shame?
I'm happy to talk with someone else about their period and share advice and similar things, but I wouldn't ever bring up my own period and when I have sexual partners I feel hugely guilty for having a period. I know this isn't right though and ok trying to figure out how to cut myself some slack because I know it's nothing shameful at all.
Re: Menstruation: Shame or No Shame?
My mom made periods a shameful subject because she was raised to talk about bodily functions only in private and use code words for them. However, once I started developing reproductive issues, read up on them, and found out how common they are, I changed my perception about talking about them. I won't mention them around guys because generally they aren't comfortable with the idea and since my 'adventures' are like the typical period x1000, I don't want to gross them out or scare them off. If a girl asks for tips for pain relief, etc., I'll help her, and I'll talk freely about my issues to close friends who don't mind, but if they're even slightly grossed out I minimize my issues to avoid bothering them.
The only exception to the men-rule is my boyfriend, because he's always been very curious about it and welcomes new information. He helps me monitor my cycles and talks me through the worst of the pain, celebrates the start of each period (as starting it means I'll finish sooner!) and celebrates the end even more as it means the end of suffering until my next bleed (I'm on hormonal birth control, so it's relatively predictable). If he could attend my doctor appointments, I think he would. ^-^ He's wonderfully caring.
However, I have some form of shame/dysphoria around my period, mostly because it's uncomfortable and I have a lot of pain much of the time. I'm not afraid of the blood, but the idea that I possess an organ that I don't wish to use for its primary biological function and which causes me pain each month (which is why I enjoyed having no period this month, though that might've been a one-time situation) makes me very uncomfortable. My goal is to either have a surgery rendering me infertile or a hysterectomy within the next few years; the first would alleviate much of my period-related anxiety and the second would fix it entirely. I'm an extreme case, though.
The only exception to the men-rule is my boyfriend, because he's always been very curious about it and welcomes new information. He helps me monitor my cycles and talks me through the worst of the pain, celebrates the start of each period (as starting it means I'll finish sooner!) and celebrates the end even more as it means the end of suffering until my next bleed (I'm on hormonal birth control, so it's relatively predictable). If he could attend my doctor appointments, I think he would. ^-^ He's wonderfully caring.
However, I have some form of shame/dysphoria around my period, mostly because it's uncomfortable and I have a lot of pain much of the time. I'm not afraid of the blood, but the idea that I possess an organ that I don't wish to use for its primary biological function and which causes me pain each month (which is why I enjoyed having no period this month, though that might've been a one-time situation) makes me very uncomfortable. My goal is to either have a surgery rendering me infertile or a hysterectomy within the next few years; the first would alleviate much of my period-related anxiety and the second would fix it entirely. I'm an extreme case, though.
-
- Similar Topics
- Replies
- Views
- Last post
-
- 7 Replies
- 4616 Views
-
Last post by Sam W
Fri Mar 22, 2024 7:03 am
-
-
New post I feel shame about buying a vibrator
by emmeline » Sun Oct 27, 2024 4:34 am » in Sex & Sexuality - 6 Replies
- 375 Views
-
Last post by Heather
Tue Oct 29, 2024 1:34 pm
-
-
-
New post Fear, shame, and anxiety over gender
by Berkeley2003 » Mon Oct 07, 2024 4:12 pm » in Ask Us! - 9 Replies
- 1219 Views
-
Last post by KierC
Mon Oct 28, 2024 10:40 am
-
-
-
New post Shame surrounding sex/sexual attraction
by carryonamelia » Sun Feb 04, 2024 5:09 pm » in Got Questions? Get Answers. - 4 Replies
- 5421 Views
-
Last post by carryonamelia
Mon Feb 05, 2024 12:27 pm
-
-
-
New post SEXUAL SHAME IS AFFECTING MY RELATIONSHIPS
by jumbomumbo » Mon Apr 01, 2024 9:46 am » in Ask Us! - 5 Replies
- 2939 Views
-
Last post by Sam W
Tue Apr 02, 2024 11:06 am
-