Butt plugs
-
Eli_314
- not a newbie
- Posts: 41
- Joined: Sun Oct 04, 2026 11:40 am
- Age: 20
- My Awesomeness Quotient: I’m very honest and sincere
- My primary language: American English
- My pronouns: He
- My sexual identity and orientation: Straight
- Location: Minneapolis
Butt plugs
Hello -
I got a new butt plug that is a little longer and quite a bit wider than the really small one I’ve had for a few weeks now. It didn’t hurt at first, but the deeper it got, it started hurting a little. Once it was in it didn’t really hurt though. And it didn’t hurt to take out. Is this normal for adjusting to a bigger size? I just wanna make sure because I don’t want to keep doing something again if it’s not safe.
I got a new butt plug that is a little longer and quite a bit wider than the really small one I’ve had for a few weeks now. It didn’t hurt at first, but the deeper it got, it started hurting a little. Once it was in it didn’t really hurt though. And it didn’t hurt to take out. Is this normal for adjusting to a bigger size? I just wanna make sure because I don’t want to keep doing something again if it’s not safe.
-
amber
- scarleteen staff/volunteer
- Posts: 285
- Joined: Thu Jun 12, 2025 7:24 am
- Age: 24
- My primary language: English
- My pronouns: she/they
- My sexual identity and orientation: bisexual
- Location: maine
Re: Butt plugs
Hi Eli_314,
That feeling is not uncommon but something we can likely work through. It may be that your body requires more lube or arousing activities prior to insertion of a bigger toy. Did you use lube when using both toys? Are you focusing on relaxation and other forms of pleasure prior to inserting the toys?
That feeling is not uncommon but something we can likely work through. It may be that your body requires more lube or arousing activities prior to insertion of a bigger toy. Did you use lube when using both toys? Are you focusing on relaxation and other forms of pleasure prior to inserting the toys?
-
Eli_314
- not a newbie
- Posts: 41
- Joined: Sun Oct 04, 2026 11:40 am
- Age: 20
- My Awesomeness Quotient: I’m very honest and sincere
- My primary language: American English
- My pronouns: He
- My sexual identity and orientation: Straight
- Location: Minneapolis
Re: Butt plugs
Yeah, I’ve used lube every time I’ve used a butt plug. And I was pretty relaxed before hand. Just wanted to check in and make sure I wasn’t feeling anything too unusual! Thank you 
-
amber
- scarleteen staff/volunteer
- Posts: 285
- Joined: Thu Jun 12, 2025 7:24 am
- Age: 24
- My primary language: English
- My pronouns: she/they
- My sexual identity and orientation: bisexual
- Location: maine
Re: Butt plugs
Of course!
It sounds like you were also getting used to using some different/higher muscles which is a likely explanation. It is important to listen to your body always but also know those feelings are not uncommon when trying new anal stimulation.
It sounds like you were also getting used to using some different/higher muscles which is a likely explanation. It is important to listen to your body always but also know those feelings are not uncommon when trying new anal stimulation.