When being gay feels wrong and right at the same time

Any questions or discussions that you ONLY want to discuss with our staff or volunteers.
(Users: please do not reply to other users here.)
bekindtomyself
newbie
Posts: 1
Joined: Fri Nov 20, 2026 10:33 am
Age: 27
My Awesomeness Quotient: i can ice skate
My primary language: english
My pronouns: she/her
My sexual identity and orientation: lesbian, queer, questioning, confused
Location: Dallas Texas

When being gay feels wrong and right at the same time

Unread post by bekindtomyself »

Hi, I’m 26 and a virgin and I think a lesbian too but sometimes I don’t think I am. I grew up in Texas. My family is religious. I grew up religious and in purity culture. Like we had purity ceremonies at the age of 12 where the pastor would declare us pure in front of the congregation and slip a ring that looks like a wedding band on our ring finger. I’m struggling a lot with my sexuality and the shame and confusion surrounding it. even though part of me feels like being attracted to women is right and feels like who I am, another part of me feels like it’s wrong, shouldn’t be real, or is something I shouldn’t allow myself to be.

I don’t even know if I’m completely certain about my identity, and I think that’s part of what’s making this so difficult. I’ve been dealing with a lot of fear about my family, my faith, and what being attracted to women could mean for my future. The church I went to acknowledged that gay people existed but still thought of it as a sin and that they should try their hardest to resist temptation. Like it's not your choice to be gay but it is your choice to act on it. It made me walk away from the church and recently I started going to an affirming church (UMC) and its helped a lot. But its really hard to undo a lot of the pain I feel. And what if I'm wrong? I've never been in a wlw relationship. What if I get in one and I then when I die I go to hell and I never see my family again? (sorry if i'm trauma dumping too much)

Sometimes I wish I could just make these feelings go away because everything surrounding them hurts so much. I came out to my mom, my sister, and my brother. My siblings love me but my mom thinks I'm not a lesbian and I'm bi and I just haven't had a relationship or given men enough of a chance.

And maybe she's right? I had a boyfriend every year in high school. I never felt an urge to have sex with them and the feeling would fizzle out a month to three months later and I would feel trapped. Then I went to college and made out with guys and didn't really feel anything but then Covid happened and I didn't go out anymore. When I was 24 I went out with a couple guys (not at the same time) and one of them I kissed and it tingled but by the next date I didn't really feel anything. No excitement. I told my mom it felt like a performance but she said it's going to be uncomfortable until it's comfortable. That that is just what it's like.

All my celebrity crushes have been women. But I don't think I ever let myself have a crush on a woman in real life. Unless they were like my figure skating coaches or something. I liked getting praised for doing something good. I liked making them smile. But I think I've had crushes on guys. I felt excited when I was kissed by the guy I went on a date with. What if I'm wrong and I'm not a lesbian? What if I just haven't tried hard enough? I feel really alone and in pain. I also haven't told my dad yet. I'm afraid of hurting him or him calling me a perversion and try to fix me. I'm in a lot of pain right now and I don't know how to fix this.

I think I mostly need someone to talk to who understands what it’s like to experience this kind of confusion and shame without pressuring me to figure everything out immediately.
Straif
scarleteen staff/volunteer
Posts: 68
Joined: Wed Jun 25, 2025 12:50 pm
Age: 41
My Awesomeness Quotient: I'm a transmasc horse girl.
My pronouns: he/him or they/them
My sexual identity and orientation: queer AF
Location: United States

Re: When being gay feels wrong and right at the same time

Unread post by Straif »

Hi bekindtomyself (I really like your username!),

If you're looking for someone who understands and isn't going to pressure you, you are very much in the right place!

I'm so sorry you've grown up in an environment where you were taught that being attracted to women meant there was something wrong with you, and I'm delighted to hear you're now in a church that understands homophobia is not a Christian value. Are there other LGBT+ folks that you could connect with there? If you're looking to build community, you can also check out Queer Grace, which has links to tons of resources, or organizations like Beloved Arise, which is an interfaith group that supports queer young people. As you seem to already be figuring out, there are MANY Christians out there who have been falsely told they have to choose between who they are and their faith. You are not alone.

Now, let's talk about being lesbian versus being bisexual. You aren't sure. And that is 100 percent normal and okay! Anyone, straight or gay, who tells you that there's anything wrong with not knowing is probably someone to avoid. Ultimately, lesbian, bisexual, or any other words we use to describe our gender and sexuality aren't boxes we're trapped in. If you feel good calling yourself a lesbian, that doesn't mean you would always have to if it turns out it stops feeling like the right descriptor-- and it wouldn't make your attraction to women any less real or valid. Same thing goes for identifying as bisexual if that feels like a better word, right now. Your mom seems like she might be assuming that being bisexual would mean you'd "naturally" still end up with a man just because you *could.* We see that response from parents a lot, so remember that being bisexual doesn't mean mom (or anyone else) gets to pressure you to continue to date men right now if you don't want to.

As for your Dad, it's heartbreaking you might have to suspect he would be so cruel. Unfortunately, it is always a possibility that people will respond poorly when we come out to them, especially at first-- and especially if they have been deeply indoctrinated over a long period of time. What I hope you'll remember is that when we come out to people, we are giving them the gift of seeing us more fully-- and, thus, loving us better. You are not placing a burden on them, and it is not your fault if they choose to see it as such. Nor do you OWE it to anyone to come out to them (although I'm guessing it's a pretty good bet he's going to find out if you've told Mom and your sisters). We can talk more about how to approach that conversation when you're ready if you want to.

At the end of the day, when, and how, and with whom you decide to have relationships and be sexual is 100 percent about what you want for yourself. You NEVER have to "try harder" to want something, nor do you need to be 100 percent sure of what you want. What matters is that you communicate your feelings and wants clearly-- and that applies regardless of who you're with.
“A home isn't always the house we live in. It's also the people we choose to surround ourselves with.”- T.J. Klune
Post Reply Previous topicNext topic
  • Similar Topics
    Replies
    Views
    Last post