Fear, shame, and anxiety over gender

[Berkeley2003]

Hi, i have a two part question! I was wondering if you have any general advice for someone who is feeling still shame and a bit of denial over settling into my gender identity, specifically leaning into my masculinity. I just feel shame for going against cisnormativity and lot of fear over being deemed attractive. I definitely think fear of being deemed attractive holds me back and tilts me towards considering femininity. I just feel dumb for holding myself back in fear or consideration of what other people think of me. In the end, I’m the one living my experience. I just feel a lot of shame around my trans identity.

My second question is advice around extreme voice dysphoria. I have pretty extreme voice dysphoria that's amplified by my preexisting OCD. Like my discomfort around my voice is something I tend to ruminate over. It's pretty exhausting. I guess my last resort is starting T soon and I have an appt booked for later this month. I guess I'm just fearful about what if it doesn't turn out going the way I want with results?

[Heather]

Hey there, Berkeley. Sorry for the wait.

In terms of your first question, what's your own community or support network like? Do you have people in it who, be they cis or trans men, possess masculinities and feelings about them you can talk with? I feel like if you had some more community to talk with about this it would likely help you work through it.

By way of that, I also want to make sure you have seen this piece, which I think offers some of what I have in mind in an editorial way: https://www.scarleteen.com/read/identit ... g-yourself

Per the second question, this sounds two-part to me: like something where I'd bring this to treatment for your OCD overall and where I'd also suggest considering things you can do to help you feel better about your voice from a trans POV. T can be one of those things, for sure, but so can gender-affirming vocal training (both are also an option): https://www.scarleteen.com/read/identit ... al-therapy

If it helps, too, to talk with someone who knows a good deal about voices (way before I did this, I was a classical voice student) and has some decidedly nonbinary feelings about the idea that voices do or even must reflect gender and can only do so in very binary and specific ways, I'm down for it.

[OpossUM?]

You’re just like me :0
I haven’t seen anyone else who has ocd like that

[Berkeley2003]

Hi Heather,

Thanks for your reply!

Yeah, I think I'm going to try and embrace more trans support group. It would just give me people to talk to and sort out my experiences. I'm going to honestly start taking the steps to start HRT and see how it goes.

Maybe there's a way to deal with this... I'm thinking more about this internal tension between "am I FTM or non-binary?" I've been going as non-binary (they/them) for a while and definitely identify more with the trans masc side than I would like to honestly admit. I was talking to my endocrinologist about something and she was like you didn't just wake up and decide you're non-binary? And just hearing that said to me, I felt detached to being called that. I just wonder if I'm just a trans man and denying it....

[KierC]

Hey there Berkeley,

I’m glad you’re considering more trans support groups. Do you have ideas of where to go for this, or would you like to talk about possible sources of community?

Here’s another resource that might help too as you pursue HRT! If you still have that appointment set for the end of the month, it may help to look through this before your appointment as it has some helpful info on what to expect from your first appointment and beyond: Trans Summer School: The Magic of Hormones

What I’m hearing is that you’re struggling with the feeling of identifying more masc, and wondering if that means you’re non-binary or FTM. I want to start by sending you this: Gender Confusion: Being Unsure Doesn’t Have To Be A Bummer. As Mo says here, being unsure of your exact gender identity is a space that many people find themselves in through their lives. You can take baby steps toward discovering words to use to describe your identity that feel right to you, and find small (and big!) joys in the process! Exploring different ways to dress, looking at different expressions of masculinity and seeing what aligns with you, these can be really fun things to do as you learn more about how you want to express yourself.

Something else that might be helpful to consider while you think about this is that there’s not a textbook definition for how any person shows up in the world based on the words they use to describe their identity. I know that sort of flexibility with identity can be daunting, but it’s more of a reminder to notice more how you feel, than how you appear according to other people. So for example, when your endocrinologist used the word non-binary in reference to you and you felt detached, that’s an important thing to listen to. On the other hand, how would you feel identifying as FTM instead of non-binary or transmasc under the non-binary umbrella?

[Berkeley2003]

Hi!

To your last question about identifying as a trans man, I honestly feel gut reaction terrified. I don't know if it's one of those things where I need to try out that identity to tease apart my emotions around it (ex: using he/him pronouns). I honestly just feel terrified when I think about it. Why do I exactly feel terrified? It just feels like such a radical shift and scares me about what people would think if I stepped into that identity to be honest.

[CaitlinEve]

That's understandable, Berkeley! It is a big change. But there's nothing that says you can't try it out and then decide that it's not something that makes you happy. There's also no guidebook for this; take it as slow or as fast as you need to. For example, you could start using he/him pronouns in one specific group of people (ie. a Discord server) just to try it out with people you trust, or with people you don't usually interact with. Just because something is a radical shift doesn't mean it's a radical shift that won't improve your life.

[Berkeley2003]

I appreciate the reframing! That definitely makes sense rationally, but it definitely freaks out the emotional side of my brain. I think I'm honestly just scared and don't know where to start, maybe it's like using those pronouns with my therapist. It's like doing some of the smallest steps is terrifying and maybe that's just unavoidable if I wanna grow as a person.

[Berkeley2003]

Hi! I apologize for back to back posting. I woke up feeling completely terrified. I'm just honestly freaking out.

I have an appointment tomorrow with my gender therapist so I think that will maybe help me emotionally regulate. I don't really know how to filter out the absolute terror and getting to the heart of my gender feelings. Or maybe that's not even possible to do it that cleanly?

[KierC]

Hey there Berkeley,

No worries — I’m glad you posted to tell us how things are going. I agree that it’ll be good to bring this to your therapist tomorrow, and that may help you regulate a bit. Your therapist may also have some recommendations or “homework” for you to do in-between sessions to help you regulate, as well. That’s something you can ask for if you haven’t spoken about that yet, too.

I hear you that it’s hard to get to the crux of your feelings about your gender when you’re feeling terrified and anxious. I agree with you that it’s not as “clean” of a process as simply filtering out the feeling of terror — I wish it were easy to just filter out anxiety, but I do think anxiety can be a cue to an emotional need we have somewhere. If we simply filter out the anxiety, the unmet need is still here. So, instead of filtering it out, gently observing the feeling of terror, noticing (without trying to immediately change anything) how this feeling shows up in your body, can sometimes help let you know which parts of yourself might need some more care in that particular moment.

How are you feeling going into therapy tomorrow? Too, in the meantime, do you have any grounding or calming strategies you use in times like this?